1972-73 FA Cup · The Final

1973 FA Cup Final: Sunderland 1-0 Leeds United

The 1973 final is remembered as the greatest FA Cup final shock, but the facts most often repeated about it need qualifying: the winning goal's minute, the timing of the double save, and whether the winning side really had no internationals at all.

Second Division Sunderland beat holders Leeds United 1-0 at Wembley to win the 1973 FA Cup, with Ian Porterfield's goal and Jim Montgomery's double save becoming part of the competition's folklore.

Sunderland Winners
1-0
Leeds United Runners-up

Saturday 5 May 1973 · Wembley Stadium

What you will not find elsewhere

From the primary record

No internationals on the day, not no internationals for good

The 1973 Sunderland side is often described as the only 20th-century FA Cup winners without full internationals. The FA's own retrospective of the final is more precise: the XI that beat Leeds featured six academy graduates and no player who had been capped at international level. Seven members of that side went on to gain international recognition afterwards. The difference matters because the familiar shorthand erases the caps that followed.[4][1]

A correction

The winning goal moves between the 31st and 32nd minute depending on the source

The standard record of the 1973 final, including the match article on Wikipedia, times Ian Porterfield's goal at the 32nd minute. The season article for the 1972-73 FA Cup and the Chronicle Live match account say it came on the half-hour, which their wording treats as the 31st minute, and the Definitive History of Leeds United and Last Word on Sports both give 31 minutes. We record 32 because it is the more widely repeated figure, but the one-minute gap is genuine and unresolved.[1][5][13][8]

A correction

Montgomery's double save is placed at four different points in the second half

The save that defined the final is reported at the 66th minute by Chronicle Live, at the 70th minute by the FA Cup Finals match timeline, after 65 minutes by the Definitive History of Leeds United, and simply as 'midway through the second half' by the standard match record. The event itself is not in doubt; only its clock position is. We describe it without a minute rather than pick one.[5][3][13]

The footage

Sunderland AFC 1-0 Leeds United | 1973 FA Cup final · Sunderland AFC · highlights
This film is genuine and officially published, but the rightsholder has switched off embedding, so it cannot play inside the page. Watch it on Sunderland AFC.

The match report

The 1973 FA Cup final was played at Wembley on Saturday 5 May 1973 between Sunderland, a Second Division club, and Leeds United, the holders and one of the strongest sides in Europe. Sunderland won 1-0 through an Ian Porterfield goal to produce one of the competition's biggest shocks.[15][4][12]

Wembley Stadium and its Twin Towers before redevelopment
Wembley Stadium and its Twin Towers, photographed at England v Sweden on 5 June 1999, not on the day of the final. User:Responsible? · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Leeds were overwhelming favourites. Don Revie's side had won the cup in 1972 and reached the final in 1970; they had beaten Norwich City, Plymouth Argyle, West Bromwich Albion, Derby County and Wolverhampton Wanderers on the way to Wembley without conceding in their last three ties. Sunderland, by contrast, were in the bottom four of the Second Division when Bob Stokoe took over in November 1972, and had needed replays to beat Notts County, Reading and Manchester City before knocking out Luton Town and Arsenal.[12][5][8][13]

Statue of Billy Bremner outside Elland Road
The statue of Leeds United captain Billy Bremner outside Elland Road, photographed in 2008. leedsyorkshire · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Sunderland began aggressively. Richie Pitt left Leeds striker Mick Jones in a heap with an early tackle that set the tone for the afternoon. On the half-hour Billy Hughes's corner was helped on by Vic Halom and Ian Porterfield controlled the ball before shooting past David Harvey from inside the penalty area.[5][13][16]

Ian Porterfield scoring the only goal of the 1973 FA Cup final
Ian Porterfield scores the only goal of the 1973 FA Cup final. Sunderland Echo photograph, permission confirmed via Wikimedia's volunteer response team. This photograph is the property of the Sunderland Echo. · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Leeds thought they had equalised soon after the restart when Trevor Cherry forced the ball in, but the goal was disallowed for a foul by Allan Clarke on Jimmy Montgomery. The decisive moment came midway through the second half. Paul Reaney crossed from the right, Cherry headed goalwards, and Montgomery dived to palm the ball away. It fell to Peter Lorimer, whose fierce shot from close range Montgomery somehow turned onto the underside of the bar before Dick Malone cleared.[5][7][13]

Jim Montgomery at the Stadium of Light in 2016
Jim Montgomery, the Sunderland goalkeeper whose double save preserved the lead, photographed at the Stadium of Light in 2016. vagueonthehow · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Sunderland held on, and Vic Halom almost made it 2-0 late on when David Harvey turned his shot away. At the final whistle Bob Stokoe ran across the Wembley turf in his trademark trilby and mac to embrace Montgomery, an image that became as famous as the result. Bobby Kerr lifted the cup and Sunderland returned north for an open-top bus parade through packed streets.[5][13][16]

Fans line the streets as the Sunderland team return home with the FA Cup
Fans line the streets as the Sunderland team return home after winning the FA Cup. Sunderland Echo photograph, circa 1973. Myosotis Scorpioides at en.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The match is remembered as a triumph for the underdog, but the facts are often smoothed out. The exact minute of the winning goal is disputed, the timing of Montgomery's double save is placed at different points in the second half, and the side is routinely described as a team without internationals, which is only true of the day itself. The FA's own retrospective records that the XI contained no capped player at the time, but that several of them went on to win international recognition.[4][13]

How the match unfolded

  1. opening minuteSunderland set the tone when Richie Pitt left Leeds striker Mick Jones in a heap with a firm tackle, a statement of intent that went unpunished.[5]
  2. 32'Ian Porterfield gives Sunderland the lead. Billy Hughes's corner is helped on by Vic Halom and Porterfield controls the ball before shooting past David Harvey.[13][5]
  3. half-timeSunderland go in 1-0 ahead, having more than matched the holders.[13][5]
  4. early second halfLeeds have the ball in the net through Trevor Cherry, but the goal is disallowed for a foul by Allan Clarke on Jimmy Montgomery.[5][13]
  5. mid second halfJim Montgomery makes the double save that defines the match, first pushing away Trevor Cherry's header and then somehow turning Peter Lorimer's close-range follow-up onto the underside of the bar.[13][5][7][16]
  6. lateVic Halom is denied a second for Sunderland by a fingertip save from David Harvey.[5][13][3]
  7. full-timeSunderland win 1-0. Bob Stokoe sprints across the Wembley turf in trilby and mac to embrace Montgomery, producing one of the most reproduced images in FA Cup history.[13][5][12]

Match facts

Date
Saturday 5 May 1973
Venue
Wembley Stadium, London
Attendance
100,000Wembley's capacity at the time. Sunderland were allocated roughly one fifth of the ground for their supporters.[15][2][3]
Referee
Ken Burns (Worcestershire County FA, Stourbridge)[13][2]
Scorers
Ian Porterfield 32'[12][15][2]
Half-time
1-0
Competition
1972-73 FA Cup

Where they played

Both sides as they lined up. Choose any player to read what they did in this final.

Sunderland · 4-4-2
1Montgomery2Malone3Guthrie4Horswill5Watson6Pitt7Kerr8Hughes9Halom10Porterfield11Tueart
Leeds United · 4-4-2
1Harvey2Reaney3Cherry4Bremner5Madeley6Hunter7Lorimer8Clarke9Jones10Giles11Gray

Select a shirt for that player's note.

Route to the final

Sunderland

  1. Third round: Notts County (a) drew 1-1, replay (h) won 2-0
  2. Fourth round: Reading (h) drew 1-1, replay (a) won 3-1
  3. Fifth round: Manchester City (a) drew 2-2, replay (h) won 3-1
  4. Sixth round: Luton Town (h) won 2-0
  5. Semi-final: Arsenal (Hillsborough) won 2-1

Leeds United

  1. Third round: Norwich City (h) drew 1-1, replay (a) drew 1-1, second replay (Villa Park) won 5-0
  2. Fourth round: Plymouth Argyle (h) won 2-1
  3. Fifth round: West Bromwich Albion (h) won 2-0
  4. Sixth round: Derby County (a) won 1-0
  5. Semi-final: Wolverhampton Wanderers (Maine Road) won 1-0

Line-ups

Sunderland · 4-4-2

  1. Jim Montgomery Goalkeeper; made the famous double save in the second half
  2. Dick Malone Right back
  3. Ron Guthrie Left back
  4. Micky Horswill Central midfield
  5. David Watson Centre back
  6. Richie Pitt Centre back; made an early tackle on Mick Jones
  7. Bobby Kerr Captain, central midfield
  8. Billy Hughes Right wing; took the corner for the winning goal
  9. Vic Halom Striker; helped on the corner for Porterfield's goal and had a late shot saved
  10. Ian Porterfield Central midfield; scored the only goal
  11. Dennis Tueart Left wing
Manager: Bob Stokoe · Captain: Bobby Kerr

Leeds United · 4-4-2

  1. David Harvey Goalkeeper
  2. Paul Reaney Right back
  3. Trevor Cherry Left back; had a header saved and a goal disallowed
  4. Billy Bremner Captain, central midfield
  5. Paul Madeley Centre back
  6. Norman Hunter Centre back
  7. Peter Lorimer Right midfield; follow-up shot was turned onto the bar
  8. Allan Clarke Forward
  9. Mick Jones Forward
  10. Johnny Giles Central midfield
  11. Eddie Gray Left midfield; substituted
Manager: Don Revie · Captain: Billy Bremner

Trivia and detail

How well do you know the 1973 final?

Five questions. Every answer is sourced from the material on this page.

  1. Who scored Sunderland's winning goal in the 1973 FA Cup final?

    Answer

    Ian Porterfield. He controlled a knock-down from Vic Halom after Billy Hughes's corner and shot past David Harvey.[13][5]

  2. Which Sunderland player made the famous double save?

    Answer

    Jim Montgomery. He first pushed away Trevor Cherry's header and then turned Peter Lorimer's close-range follow-up onto the underside of the bar.[13][7]

  3. What division was Sunderland playing in when they won the 1973 FA Cup?

    Answer

    Second Division. They were a Second Division club and the first from outside the top flight to win the cup since West Bromwich Albion in 1931.[15][13]

  4. Who was Sunderland's manager in the 1973 FA Cup final?

    Answer

    Bob Stokoe. Bob Stokoe took over during the season when Sunderland were near the bottom of the Second Division and led them to the cup.[13][4]

  5. Which Leeds player hit the follow-up shot that Jim Montgomery turned onto the bar?

    Answer

    Peter Lorimer. Lorimer drove the ball goalwards from close range after Montgomery had parried Cherry's header, and Montgomery somehow diverted it onto the underside of the bar.[13][5]

What is not settled

Honesty matters more than tidiness. These details are contested or unrecorded, and we have not guessed at them:

How we know

Every claim on this page is tied to a numbered source below. These are the contemporary records behind it, each one fetched and matched word for word before publication rather than taken on trust:

Where a primary record and a modern account disagree, we show both rather than choosing the tidier number.

Sources

  1. 1973 FA Cup final · Wikipedia
  2. 1973 FA Cup Final Result · Sporting Chronicle
  3. Sunderland A.F.C. vs Leeds United 1973 FA Cup Final Timeline · FA Cup Finals
  4. Sunderland hero Dennis Tueart looks back on 1973 · The Football Association
  5. Sunderland 1973 Road to Wembley relived: Glory, glory, Hallelujah as the FA Cup comes to Wearside · Chronicle Live
  6. Sunderland's 1973 Road to Wembley relived: Watson and Guthrie down Luton to earn semi-final spot · Chronicle Live
  7. Wembley 1973: Monty's save of the century · The Northern Echo
  8. On This Day: 1973 FA Cup Final - Sunderland v Leeds United · Last Word on Sports
  9. 7 April 1973 - Leeds United 1 Wolverhampton Wanderers 0 · The Definitive History of Leeds United
  10. Sunderland AFC - Luton Town, 17/03/1973 - FA Cup · Transfermarkt
  11. Derby County - Leeds United, 17/03/1973 - FA Cup · Transfermarkt
  12. England FA Challenge Cup 1972-73 · RSSSF
  13. 5 May 1973 - Sunderland 1 Leeds United 0, FA Cup final · The Definitive History of Leeds United
  14. The full list of Sunderland AFC 1973 FA Cup winners who will get the freedom of the city · Chronicle Live
  15. Call to honour the 'overlooked' Sunderland players of SAFC's 1973 FA Cup glory · Sunderland Echo
  16. Sunderland mark 50 years since FA Cup glory · ITV News Tyne Tees
  17. Classic match: 1973 FA Cup final · Sunderland AFC

Elsewhere on WhatChan