2011-12 FA Cup · The Final
2012 FA Cup Final: Chelsea 2-1 Liverpool
The FA's own report of its own final names the wrong assistant referee for the goal that never was, and no two records of this match agree on the minute of almost anything that happened.
Chelsea won their fourth FA Cup in six seasons, beating Liverpool 2-1 at Wembley, but the final is remembered for the Andy Carroll header that Petr Cech clawed on to the bar and that nobody will ever prove did or did not cross the line.
Saturday 5 May 2012 · Wembley Stadium
What you will not find elsewhere
The FA's own report of its own final names the wrong assistant referee for the decision the match turned on
When Petr Cech clawed Andy Carroll's header on to the bar, the goal was not given on the say-so of the assistant referee on that side of the pitch. The Football Association's official match report of the final records that neither referee Phil Dowd or his assistant Stuart Burt were convinced the ball had crossed the line. But two independent contemporary accounts name the other assistant. The BBC's chief football writer Phil McNulty wrote that referee Phil Dowd and assistant referee Andrew Garratt waved play on, and RTE's report states Linesman Andrew Garratt was not so sure. Burt and Garratt were the two assistants that day, and the header was aimed at the far post on Garratt's side. The governing body's own account of its own showpiece names the wrong official, and it has stood uncorrected on the archived page ever since. We follow the two independent reports and name Garratt.[1][2][7]
Three records of this final, and almost none of the timings agree
We compared every timed event in the FA's official report, Sky Sports' match record and the standard reference work. The FA says Chelsea led after just ten minutes; everybody else says the 11th minute. Carroll came on at 54 (standard) or 55 (Sky and the FA). Meireles replaced Ramires at 76 (Sky) or 77 (FA). Kuyt replaced Bellamy at 76 (standard), 78 (Sky) or 79 (FA). Mikel's booking is timed at 36 or 37 minutes, Agger's at 44 or 45, and the disallowed header is placed in the 81st minute by the standard work and RTE but with eight minutes left by the BBC. No source is careless here: they are three different people with three different stopwatches, and the drift is exactly why this page keeps every disagreement visible rather than silently picking one.[1][12][13][2]
'Correctly never given'? The FA's verdict on the Carroll header is far stronger than any neutral account
The FA's official report is certain: the header was correctly never given. Nobody independent goes that far. The BBC's match report says even a succession of replays proving inconclusive; the Guardian called the replays at best inconclusive; RTE wrote that even after half a dozen replays, there was no clear verdict either way. Even the BBC's separate report of the Liverpool reaction could only manage that replays suggested the right decision had been made. Fourteen months later, in July 2013, the Premier League adopted goal-line technology, and incidents like this one were the case made for it. The honest record of this moment is not that the officials were right or wrong. It is that nobody could tell, including the people paid to decide.[1][2][7][8][3]
The footage
The match report
Chelsea won the FA Cup for the seventh time on Saturday 5 May 2012, beating Liverpool 2-1 in the 131st final of the competition, watched by 89,102 at Wembley. Ramires scored early, Didier Drogba doubled the lead just after half-time and, though substitute Andy Carroll pulled one back and came within inches of a dramatic equaliser, Chelsea held on to lift the cup for the fourth time in six seasons.[1][2][12][13]
The final was not even the last match of the English season. UEFA wanted a clear four-week gap between the end of the domestic calendar and Euro 2012, and with the Champions League final a fortnight away the FA brought its showpiece forward to the first weekend of May, where it clashed with a full Premier League programme for the second year running. Kick-off was moved to 5.15pm so the league games finished first, and the oddest twist of all was that the two finalists had been due to meet each other at Anfield in the league that same day. The fixture was postponed to the Tuesday, so Chelsea and Liverpool played each other twice in four days.[9][10][13]
Liverpool's first final at the new Wembley began badly and never really recovered. Jay Spearing lost possession in midfield, the ball broke to Juan Mata, and his pass sent Ramires beyond Jose Enrique; the Brazilian drove into the area and beat Pepe Reina at the near post with a shot the goalkeeper should have saved. Liverpool almost hit back within two minutes when Craig Bellamy's volley was blocked in front of goal by Branislav Ivanovic, but Steven Gerrard was forced ever deeper to help a swamped midfield and Luis Suarez was left isolated. John Obi Mikel was booked for a mistimed tackle on Gerrard, and Daniel Agger followed him into Phil Dowd's book for a challenge on Mikel before the break.[2][1][7][13]
Liverpool began the second half brightly and had a penalty appeal waved away when Gerrard went down in the area, but two minutes later the final tilted decisively. Frank Lampard escaped Spearing and fed Drogba, who held off Martin Skrtel and sent a left-footed finish across Reina into the far corner. It made Drogba the first man to score in four FA Cup finals, and it was his eighth goal in as many Wembley appearances. Kenny Dalglish responded by sending on Carroll for Spearing.[2][1][7]
The substitution transformed the match. Inside ten minutes of coming on, Carroll had scored: Stewart Downing charged down Jose Bosingwa's attempted clearance, the ricochet fell to the substitute, and he turned John Terry superbly before smashing a left-footed shot high past Petr Cech. Suddenly Liverpool were laying siege. Gerrard volleyed over from Carroll's knock-down, Cech saved low from Suarez, and Agger headed wide from the corner that followed. Chelsea, who had been cruising, were now clinging on, and Roberto Di Matteo sent on Raul Meireles for Ramires to stiffen the midfield.[2][1][13]
Then came the moment the final is remembered for. With nine minutes left Suarez chipped a cross to the far post and Carroll powered a header goalwards; Cech, stretching back, got a hand to it and turned the ball on to the underside of the bar and away. Carroll ran off celebrating, certain it had crossed the line, but referee Phil Dowd and his assistant Andrew Garratt were unmoved, and Suarez was booked amid the protests. A succession of television replays proved inconclusive either way. The FA's own report of the final declares the attempt was 'correctly never given' - and names the assistant on that side as Stuart Burt, who was actually the official on the opposite touchline.[2][7][1][8]
Chelsea saw out five minutes of added time, John Terry became the first man to captain a club to four FA Cup victories, and Ashley Cole collected his seventh winners' medal. The strangest of seasons then produced one more twist: three days later, at the rearranged Anfield league fixture, Liverpool won 4-1 against a Chelsea side resting several regulars for Munich. Liverpool still finished eighth in the league and Dalglish was sacked on 16 May. Chelsea finished sixth, won the Champions League on penalties against Bayern Munich on 19 May, and Di Matteo was given the manager's job permanently.[1][5][13]
What the win was worth in money is printed on the FA's own report, which records that the winning club received 1,800,000 pounds from the prize fund and the runners-up 950,000 pounds. Both clubs would have traded it for what came next: for Chelsea the European Cup a fortnight later, for Liverpool nothing at all. The defeat hardened the view of Liverpool's owners, and within a fortnight Dalglish was gone, replaced by Brendan Rodgers.[1][13][5]
How the match unfolded
- 11'Jay Spearing loses possession in midfield, the ball breaks to Juan Mata and his pass sends Ramires beyond Jose Enrique. The Brazilian drives into the area and beats Pepe Reina at the near post. The FA's own report times the goal 'after just ten minutes'; every other record says the 11th.[2][1][12]
- 13'Liverpool almost equalise immediately. Glen Johnson's cross reaches Craig Bellamy, whose goalbound volley is blocked in front of the line by Branislav Ivanovic.[1][2][13]
- 36'John Obi Mikel is shown the first yellow card of the final for a mistimed tackle on Steven Gerrard. Sky Sports times the booking at 37 minutes.[13][12]
- 44'Daniel Agger is booked for a challenge on Mikel. Sky Sports times it at 45 minutes.[13][12]
- 50'Liverpool's penalty appeal is waved away after Gerrard goes down in the Chelsea area.[13]
- 52'Frank Lampard escapes Spearing and feeds Didier Drogba, who holds off Martin Skrtel and sends a left-footed finish across Reina into the far corner. It makes Drogba the first man to score in four FA Cup finals.[2][1][7]
- 55'Kenny Dalglish sends on Andy Carroll for Spearing. The standard reference work gives 54 minutes.[12][1][13]
- 64'Carroll scores. Stewart Downing charges down Jose Bosingwa's attempted clearance, the ricochet falls to the substitute and he turns John Terry before smashing a left-footed shot high past Petr Cech.[2][1][12]
- 71'Carroll's headed pass finds Gerrard, whose shot goes over the crossbar.[13]
- 73'Cech saves low from Suarez, and Agger heads wide from the corner that follows.[13][1]
- 76'Raul Meireles replaces Ramires as Chelsea try to stiffen the midfield. The FA's report times it at 77.[12][1]
- 78'Dirk Kuyt replaces Bellamy. The FA's report times it at 79, the standard reference work at 76.[12][1][13]
- 80'Downing's clever pass inside Bosingwa sets Suarez free, but his miscued cut-back is eventually fired over by Jordan Henderson.[1]
- 81'The moment the final is remembered for. Suarez chips a cross to the far post, Carroll powers a header goalwards and Cech claws it on to the underside of the bar and away. Carroll celebrates, certain it crossed the line, but Phil Dowd and assistant Andrew Garratt do not award a goal. Suarez is booked amid the protests. The BBC times the incident with eight minutes left.[13][7][2][12]
- 90'Florent Malouda replaces Mata as Chelsea run the clock down.[12][1]
- 95'After five minutes of added time, Dowd blows for full-time and Chelsea win the FA Cup.[1]
Match facts
Where they played
Both sides as they lined up. Choose any player to read what they did in this final.
Select a shirt for that player's note.
Route to the final
Chelsea
- Third round: Portsmouth (h) won 4-0
- Fourth round: Queens Park Rangers (a) won 1-0
- Fifth round: Birmingham City (h) drew 1-1, replay (a) won 2-0
- Quarter-final: Leicester City (h) won 5-2
- Semi-final: Tottenham Hotspur (Wembley) won 5-1
Liverpool
- Third round: Oldham Athletic (h) won 5-1
- Fourth round: Manchester United (h) won 2-1
- Fifth round: Brighton & Hove Albion (h) won 6-1
- Quarter-final: Stoke City (h) won 2-1
- Semi-final: Everton (Wembley) won 2-1
Line-ups
Chelsea · 4-2-3-1
- Petr Cech Goalkeeper. Clawed Carroll's late header on to the bar in the moment the final turned on
- Jose Bosingwa Right back. His attempted clearance was charged down by Downing for Liverpool's goal
- Branislav Ivanovic Centre back. Blocked Bellamy's goalbound volley; already banned from the Champions League final
- John Terry Captain, centre back. The first man to captain a side to four FA Cup wins
- Ashley Cole Left back. Collected a record seventh FA Cup winners' medal
- John Obi Mikel Central midfield. Booked for a mistimed tackle on Gerrard
- Frank Lampard Central midfield. Escaped Spearing and fed Drogba for the second goal
- Ramires Right of the three. Scored the opener; his European semi-final booking already ruled him out of Munich
- Juan Mata Attacking midfield. Man of the match; slid the pass through for the opening goal
- Salomon Kalou Left of the three
- Didier Drogba Striker. Scored the second goal, becoming the first man to score in four FA Cup finals
Liverpool · 4-2-3-1
- Pepe Reina Goalkeeper. Beaten at his near post for the opening goal
- Glen Johnson Right back. His cross created Bellamy's first-half chance
- Martin Skrtel Centre back. Held off by Drogba for the second goal
- Daniel Agger Centre back. Booked late in the first half for a challenge on Mikel
- Jose Enrique Left back. Beaten too easily by Ramires for the opening goal
- Jordan Henderson Central midfield. Fired over Liverpool's late cut-back chance
- Jay Spearing Central midfield. Lost possession in the build-up to the opener; replaced by Carroll
- Craig Bellamy Right of the three. Denied by Ivanovic's block; replaced by Kuyt
- Steven Gerrard Captain, behind the striker. Forced deep to help a swamped midfield
- Stewart Downing Left of the three. Charged down Bosingwa's clearance to create Carroll's goal
- Luis Suarez Striker. Crossed for Carroll's disallowed header and was booked in the protests
Trivia and detail
- Juan Mata was named man of the match. His slide-rule pass created Ramires' opening goal.[13]
- John Terry became the first player to captain a side to four separate FA Cup victories, and Ashley Cole collected his seventh winners' medal, extending his own record.[1]
- ITV's live match coverage averaged 8.9 million viewers with a five-minute peak of 11.21 million, the biggest audience for a final since 2007. ESPN's coverage drew 397,000.[11]
- Each club was allocated approximately 25,000 tickets, almost 7,000 fewer per team than for the semi-finals. Kenny Dalglish said supporters were being taken for granted.[6]
- Liverpool fans could barely get to the final at all: engineering works meant only three direct trains ran from Liverpool to London that day, all leaving before 8am, and no train home was possible after a 5.15pm kick-off.[10]
- The final began with 85 million pounds of striking talent on the bench: Andy Carroll for Liverpool and Fernando Torres, against his former club, for Chelsea.[2][7]
- Ramires was the first Brazilian to score in an FA Cup final.[7]
- Ramires and Branislav Ivanovic played the whole final knowing their bookings in the Champions League semi-final had already ruled them out of the Munich final a fortnight later.[7]
- In the rearranged league meeting at Anfield three days after the final, Stewart Downing missed a penalty and hit the woodwork twice, yet Liverpool still won 4-1.[5]
How well do you know the 2012 final?
Five questions. Every answer is sourced from the material on this page.
-
Who scored Chelsea's opening goal in the 2012 FA Cup final?
-
Which Liverpool substitute scored and then had a header controversially not given?
-
Who refereed the 2012 FA Cup final?
-
What record did Didier Drogba set by scoring in the 2012 final?
Answer
First man to score in four FA Cup finals. His left-footed finish made him the first man to score in four FA Cup finals, and was his eighth goal in as many Wembley appearances.[7]
-
The two clubs met again in the league three days after the final. What happened?
Answer
Liverpool won 4-1 at Anfield. Liverpool gained emphatic revenge at Anfield against a Chelsea side resting players for the Champions League final, ending the Blues' top-four hopes.[5]
What is not settled
Honesty matters more than tidiness. These details are contested or unrecorded, and we have not guessed at them:
- The minute of the opening goal is contested by the governing body itself. The FA's official match report says Chelsea led 'after just ten minutes'; the BBC, Sky Sports and the standard reference work all give the 11th minute. We publish 11.
- The disallowed header is placed in the 81st minute by the standard reference work and by RTE, while the BBC describes it with eight minutes left, which implies the 82nd. Sky Sports times Suarez's booking in its aftermath at 82. We publish 81.
- Booking minutes drift between records: Mikel's yellow card is 36 in the standard work and 37 on Sky Sports; Agger's is 44 or 45. We publish the standard work's figures.
- Substitution minutes drift the same way: Carroll came on at 54 or 55, Meireles at 76 or 77, and Kuyt at 76, 78 or 79 depending on which record is consulted. We publish the figures Sky Sports and the FA agree on where they do agree.
- Which assistant referee ruled on the disallowed header is recorded incorrectly somewhere. The FA's own report names Stuart Burt; the BBC and RTE both name Andrew Garratt, whose side of the pitch the far-post header was aimed at. We name Garratt.
- Whether Carroll's header crossed the line is genuinely unsettled. The FA's report asserts it was correctly not given; the BBC, the Guardian and RTE all describe the replays as inconclusive. We record it as contested, not settled.
- No footage has been verified for this final yet, so the television shows no signal rather than an unchecked embed.
How we know
Every claim on this page is tied to a numbered source below. These are the contemporary records behind it, each one fetched and matched word for word before publication rather than taken on trust:
- Nicholas Veevers, The FA's official match report, 5 May 2012, archived 7 May 2012 · The Football Association (archived)
- Phil McNulty, chief football writer, 5 May 2012 · BBC Sport
- Post-match reaction, 5 May 2012 · BBC Sport
- Phil McNulty, post-match reaction, 5 May 2012 · BBC Sport
- Phil Dawkes, 8 May 2012 · BBC Sport
- Ticket allocation report, 18 April 2012 · BBC Sport
- Match report, 5 May 2012 · RTE Sport
- Dominic Fifield at Wembley, 5 May 2012 · The Guardian
- Scheduling announcement report, 12 May 2011 · The Guardian
- Travel disruption report, 16 April 2012 · The Guardian
- Overnight ratings report, 8 May 2012 · The Guardian
Where a primary record and a modern account disagree, we show both rather than choosing the tidier number.
Sources
- Chelsea's day · The Football Association (archived)
- Chelsea 2-1 Liverpool · BBC Sport
- Kenny Dalglish hopes Liverpool learn from cup finals · BBC Sport
- Roberto Di Matteo 'relaxed' over Chelsea job · BBC Sport
- Liverpool 4-1 Chelsea · BBC Sport
- Liverpool boss Kenny Dalglish says fans are 'taken for granted' · BBC Sport
- Chelsea 2-1 Liverpool · RTE Sport
- Kenny Dalglish laments Liverpool's naivety and nerves against Chelsea · The Guardian
- No escape for 2012 FA Cup final from date clash with Premier League · The Guardian
- Liverpool fans face huge disruption travelling to London for Cup final · The Guardian
- Chelsea v Liverpool FA Cup final scores peak of 11 million viewers · The Guardian
- Chelsea vs Liverpool: The FA Cup Final, line-ups and match record · Sky Sports
- 2012 FA Cup final · Wikipedia